HP Challenges Dell for PC Market Lead as Slowing Demand in the United States Limits Worldwide Growth, According to IDC
FRAMINGHAM, MA – OCTOBER 18, 2006 – Worldwide PC shipment growth slipped to 7.9% in the third quarter of the year, according to IDC's Worldwide Quarterly PC Tracker. Overall growth was down from 9.8% in the second quarter and double-digit growth over the prior three years. International shipments continued to expand at roughly 11% year on year, but slow growth in the United States pulled down overall results.
Growth in Europe has recovered after a slow second quarter, but a similar adjustment seems to have occurred in the United States during the third quarter. With a dominant share of the U.S. market and in the midst of efforts to refocus its business, Dell felt the brunt of the shortfall with shipments falling nearly 7% year on year in the U.S. Hewlett-Packard was able to leverage strong growth in international markets and relatively strong performance in the United States to boost overall volume incrementally ahead of its rival. Although HP volume was larger by roughly 28 thousand units, on volumes of nearly 10 million, IDC considers this is a statistical tie.
The outlook for growth in the second half of the year has been under some scrutiny as replacement activity has declined and the delayed launch of Vista gets more attention. Spotty growth in some markets contributed to these concerns, but the overall outlook has remained fairly positive.
"This quarter's results show a similar volatility to last quarter, with strong international sales and growth in portables reflecting continued demand while we saw weak results for Dell and the U.S. market overall," said Loren Loverde, director of IDC's Worldwide Quarterly PC Tracker. "Dell has had some negative publicity recently regarding its battery recall but it is hard to attribute the third quarter results to bad publicity alone. Dell will likely be very aggressive in the fourth quarter, and we will see how similar battery recalls affect other vendors. These factors may cut into fourth quarter growth, but overall we don't see a broad threat to fourth quarter growth."
"In the U.S. market, the focus continues to be on the transition from desktops to notebooks, with notebook growth being the sole bright spot while desktop shipments continued to decline," said Bob O'Donnell, vice president, Clients and Displays at IDC. "The impact of Dell's decline was particularly acute in the U.S. and led to a shrinking of the market versus the same period last year."
— United States – Slower than expected growth from Dell, which represents roughly a third of U.S. PC shipments, weighed heavily on growth in the United States. Overall, portables growth slipped quickly into single digits, significantly constraining the primary market driver. Despite disappointing results in the third quarter, IDC expect vendors to step up promotions in the fourth quarter to sustain growth.
— EMEA – After a slower second quarter impacted by the World Cup and channel inventory clearance, 3Q06 managed to beat expectations at 10% growth. This growth was driven by a buoyant back-to-school season and continued demand for notebooks, although consumer desktop demand continued to lag despite aggressive promotions in retail channels. Recent demand and a relatively clear channel support a solid outlook for the region.
— Japan – The Japanese market suffered another quarter of declining growth as commercial shipments remained flat and consumer volume fell in the face of competition from LCD TVs and other products. Dell continued to grow in solid double-digits year on year while most of its competitors declined. Still, seasonality played an important roll as Dell saw a sequential decline while top competitors saw volume increase from the prior quarter.
— Asia/Pacific (excluding Japan) – Growth in APeJ remained in double digits, with a strong showing from large regions and market leaders. China met expectations while India and South Korea saw increased demand.
— HP had a very solid quarter, catching up to Dell after trailing its rival since the end of 2003. Growth in the United States slowed from recent quarters, but remained well ahead of the market and Dell. The company also saw important gains internationally, with strong growth in Europe and emerging regions.
— Dell saw strong growth in international markets – particularly in Asia/Pacific, Japan, and Latin America. However, growth in EMEA was slightly behind the market, and in the United States, which represents over 50% of its shipments, Dell saw volume decline by nearly 7% year on year with a double-digit decline in desktops.
— Lenovo grew slightly faster than the market again on the strength of its Asia/Pacific business. The company also saw a positive improvement in its European business. However, a stronger second quarter in the U.S. gave way to further contraction in the United States and Japan.
— Acer continues to grow at a rapid pace with solid gains across regions. Growth in Europe – which represent the bulk of the business – improved notably from an already solid base, while growth in other regions was more moderate than recent quarters, but still quite strong. Acer remains well positioned and poised to leverage its position in portables and other growth areas.
— Toshiba continued to benefit from strong demand for portables as growth remained solidly in double digits. EMEA, as well as other international markets, remained particularly strong for Toshiba.
— Gateway had a slow quarter, pulled down by lackluster consumer demand in the United States. International shipments grew in double digits and on par with the market. Growth in the U.S. was flat after several quarters of strong gains. Although the soft U.S. market meant Gateway's growth kept pace in individual markets, the company's focus on the U.S. limited its overall growth.
— Apple had a very good quarter with shipments increasing more than 30% in all regions except Japan. The growth is an excellent sign of the success of Apple's transition to Intel based systems.
Top 5 Vendors, Worldwide PC Shipments, Third Quarter 2006 (Preliminary)
(Units Shipments are in thousands)
Rank Vendor Q3 2006 Shipments Market Share Q3 2005 Shipments Market Share 3Q06/3Q07 Growth
1 HP 9,831 17.2% 8,540 16.1% 15.1%
1 Dell 9,803 17.2% 9,465 17.9% 3.6%
3 Lenovo 4,447 7.8% 4,054 7.7% 9.7%
4 Acer 3,418 6.0% 2,546 4.8% 34.3%
5 Toshiba 2,385 4.2% 1,982 3.7% 20.4%
Others 27,168 47.6% 26,292 49.7% 3.3%
All Vendors 57,052 100.0% 52,879 100.0% 7.9%
— Shipments include shipments to distribution channels or end users. OEM sales are counted under the vendor/brand under which they are sold.
— PCs include Desktop, Notebook, Ultra Portable, and x86 Servers.
— PCs do not include handhelds. Data for all vendors are reported for calendar periods.
Source: IDC, October 18, 2006
Top 5 Vendors, U.S. PC Shipments, Third Quarter 2006 (Preliminary)
(Units Shipments are in thousands)
Rank Vendor Q3 2006 Shipments Market Share Q3 2005 Shipments Market Share 3Q06/3Q05 Growth
1 Dell 5,258 31.0% 5,638 33.0% -6.7%
2 HP 3,725 22.0% 3,486 20.4% 6.9%
3 Gateway 1,023 6.0% 1,020 6.0% 0.3%
4 Apple 975 5.8% 737 4.3% 32.3%
5 Toshiba 715 4.2% 664 3.9% 7.6%
Others 5,260 31.0% 5,532 32.4% -4.9%
All Vendors 16,956 100.0% 17,077 100.0% -0.7%